Former chief of Indian National Congress (INC), Sonia Gandhi, launched her memoir 'Belonging - A Journey of Love' on 16 Nov. Copies of the book were available a week in advance. Gandhi is reticent, but her memoir is heartfelt. It tells the story of an ordinary girl thrust into the center stage of India's politics as the daughter-in-law of a very powerful political family, and how it impacted her. A memoir also becomes a space for the writer to share her views on public events from her time. Gandhi's views on Panjab militancy and the then Prime Minister Indira Gandhi (and her mother-in-law) ordering ‘Operation Blue Star’—the attack on Darbar Sahib (Golden Temple) complex and more than a hundred Gurdwaras throughout Panjab by the Indian Army in June 1984—do not differ much from what earlier books have recorded. On the 1984 Sikh Genocide, Gandhi brings up a piece of information which she does not back with evidence. On page 264, she says: 'Although the Chief of Army Staff General AS Vaidya had received his orders the same night as the assassination, we heard later that he decided not to mobilise the nearest units because they were manned by Sikh soldiers...' Gandhi is deflecting the issue from the INC government then in power. Advocate HS Phoolka says that the Army's job is to be ready and, according to the Nanavati Commission, 6,100 soldiers were ready in Delhi. It is the civil administration's job to summon and deploy the Army. Phoolka adds that former Prime Minister IK Gujral and retired Lieutenant General Jagjit Singh Arora met with then President Giani Zail Singh on 1 Nov 1984. The President expressed his helplessness to do anything. They next met the Union Home Minister PV Narasimha Rao, who said the Army was needed to provide security to various dignitaries attending PM Indira Gandhi's funeral. Gandhi does not answer why, when she was INC chief, alleged perpetrators of the genocide such as Jagdish Tytler and Kamal Nath kept holding ministerial positions. Her approach to the genocide remains casual when she could have used the opportunity to make a sincere apology to the Sikhs on behalf of the Gandhi family and the INC. In parallel, at the behest of Bharatiya Janata Party leader Manjinder Singh Sirsa, Delhi Sikh Gurdwara Management Committee chief Harmeet Singh Kalka, and others burnt copies of the book. It is ironic because Sikhi teaches responding to, challenging, and reinforcing the narrative, not serving as pawns for a political party (earlier coverage).






